@Iacob Ovidiu :)

@patrice decourcy, even you!

Yeah, we remember - you were so wrong :)

I don't think henry has the right upper body strength yet

Good grief! No offense, but - What’s wrong with you?!? Do you realize almost EVERYONE loves this series?!!

This is normally the case with ALOT of mini series! They lure you in and then drag it out until the last ep. This wouldn’t suck as much if they revealed actual good stuff along the way but nope. Also when you can follow a tv series just by written recaps alone you’ve already lost

@irene bee I’m just speculating but I definitely believe it’s her husband! I have from day one but I did think for a split second that grace could of did it unconsciously!!

@Bye Felicia the killer is her husband or GRACE's father, please tell me, cant wait till next monday

I didn’t even read the book and I knew who the killer was from day one! But I appreciate the twists and turns! I definitely thought the wife may have killer her and not realized it in the beginning but no, I’m firm in who I think it is! And it’s not the wife lol!

And you win!

Yup

I agree

She had the affair with him but I still think Jonathan is the one that killed Elena. Like a true sociopath

Sylvia, and yes I suspect that she had something going on with Jonathan. She broke confidentiality with him to Grace for a reason, she had to make an excuse for seeing him without her knowledge.

I think same way

They're ALL good !

@irene bee bcouse maybe he was her lover or something and he saw her with jonathan at the studioand thats why he wants him in jail and never suspect elenas husband .I think that in this kind of movies at the end the murder is the guy u didnt expect

why would the cop kill Elena?

Ooooo interestingggg

I believe this to be a likely, most likely scenario

@Regulus Sky wow great theory! I still think it’ll be Jonathan but this is a fantastic theory and would make for a pretty epic finale!

Nah thats a total copout

Regulus Sky Oh My Gosh! If you’re right, I’m very surprised. But it makes sense! I can’t deny.

On point ;) "undoing" is a psychiatry term used when somebody do or is victim of some traumatic event and this person blocks it like amnesia. Grace seems to have fully forgotten about her relationship with Elena(the kiss), Grace also displayed some moments of sudden forgetfulness and flashbacks. My guess is that she had her own affair with Elena, snapped and killed her. The reason she would smash her face like that is because Grace was fascinated by Elena's beauty. That episode with Elena's portrait of Grace makes me think Grace actually played a model for Elena but she just doesn't remember. As for the hammer, I would say she hid it in her son's bedroom or the son knew that Grace did it and hid the hammer to protect his mom.

Ffs

I mean, why hire Lily Rabe for a nothing role, right?

she is the other woman he had a 'sad fuck' with im betting, maybe she was jealous of Elena

@Holly Munn your Ma May be spot on! Look forward to the endgame. She’s always been lurking. But it may just be a red Herring. Time will tell

@seriouslyjoking2 we shall see! Can’t wait :)

I think she is Katie the Kitten.

100% agree

@Beth Snyder I think they can do it as they did with Defending Jacob. Since Jonathan isn't even there throughout the book it's just another modification. I do prefer to watch something slightly different.

Yea I’m like it’s very obvious who did it but the twists and turns are A LITTLE interesting!

I think they did that to take it to TV and add their twist, but would piss off alot of readers if they deviated too far from the book.

@Agnes M LMAO !

lol

wouldn't he also have his mother's dna?

Hmmmmm that's a long shot. I think the biggest plot twist they can do at this point and a logical one is that Jonathan actually did it and they just got us guessing for 4 episodes. The night of the murderer he hid the hammer in the house and then flew. Henry found the hammer one of the next days (before the police search) and hid it to protect his father. Then he took it it his grand-father house and it has been there ever since.

I think Grace did it. Even if it's just for the fact that she didn't even flinch when they showed the image of the dead girl's face.

@Regulus Sky I guess you pointed out some fair arguments regarding the motive. It would be an interesting plot twist if Grace was the one who did it in the end...

@newcoore1 I don't think he would leave the body there knowing that Jonathan would easily become the main suspect in case he did that to save Grace's marriage, also for the father to do that to Elena with so much rage like it's personal, no way. IF the father did it, he didn't do it to save Grace's marriage BUT to destroy it, again, as he knew that they would have Jonathan for suspect, but still, considering all the many other hints I'm pretty sure it was Grace who killed Elena. Also, if Sylvia was the prior affair of Jonathan, she would be dead as well. To me, Grace was in a love relationship with Elena, found out about her affair with Jonathan or someone else, felt jealousy for Elena and beaten her until destroy her face because Grace wanted to forget about her, and she did. Grace doesn't remember any of her private moments with Elena, in one of the early episodes Grace mentioned that she not even spoke to Elena. Grace could have told the police that Elena kissed her and that she was stalking her to support the early Jonathan's theory that Elena was crazy, but Grace didn't mention anything because she doesn't even remember about the kiss either.

@urshii the murder is the main talk where they live, everyone knows where Elena's apartment is.

@Regulus Sky he did advise that after Jonathan was convicted no? I mean, I see him as a father who loves his daughter and does not want to see her experiencing a life with a cheating husband (he himself cheated and later regretted it). I mean there is a lot of stuff going on. We'll see next week but this is my best guess.

Me too!!! Sure she had something with the husband!

I think the same, but my guess is that something happens while she's night walking. Maybe that's the moment when she does stuff and forgets, so she's unaware that's even happening. There were cases of forgetfulness displayed by her, like forgetting things she said to her son, she also seems to have completely blocked any moments with Elena. My guess is that when Elena kissed Grace by the elevator they were in a relationship already, but Grace wasn't even fully aware of that, and only her nocturnal counterpart was being part of it.

That is what I thought, too!

no shit!

@janedci I don't think so. He was already portrayed as an unpredictable man.

Could have been the grandfather

At most he's only hid the hammer to protect his mom, since certainly Grace killed Elena.

You mean the actor?

I think it’s more like Jonathan manipulated him to hide the hammer not just planting it cause like grace said Henry would do anything for him

@Francisco Alves yes he did, when he got home in the morning. Grace grills her son about him saying goodbye to him in the morning when he always does at night, he went in there in the morning and hid it.

Jonathan never had the opportunity to do that

Maybe he did have some fun with Sylvia, but Sylvia didn't kill Elena.

Sylvia! I think she was ''the other woman'' as well. another affair.

I dont think Henry did it either. I believe Jonathan killed her and it is the thrill of cluckholding everyone into believing he is iinnocent. It is part of his sociapathic and narcissistic personality. He lacks empathy and only cares he got away with it. That is the point of the show it takes off all gingers pointing to him.

My guess it is the husband. I pegged him all along. He is a narcissistic sociopath.

Since the 1st ep.,I truly wonder why everyone thinks that every time we see a scene from the murder or Helena or the past in general that means it's in Grace's mind.. No. They just show us how things probably went down according to what 's being said. It' s not what Grace thinks or remembers imo..

'Tis possible❣️ It's a theory many of us have considered from the start (or at least by episode 2). Regardless... It certainly lives up to it, even satiates and pleases so many of us❣️ _And now..._ *"Big Sky".* 😌🩸🥰

@Regulus Sky I am aware. It also could refer to her perfect life falling apart. The show is base on the book "You should have know known". So I don't know if they are going to stick to the Original ending, or change it to someone else.

@luvprue1 "undoing" is a term in psychology to describe when the brain blocks a traumatic memory of something someone did or suffered from. Grace seems to have completely forgotten about being kissed by Elena and even that she speaked to her, after Elena got murdered. Grace displayed episodes of forgetfulness, there's also the flashbacks which initially makes us think they're coming from Jonathan but I'm convinced they actually comes from Grace. My guess is that whenever she's night walking she does things she forgets by the morning, like she's sleep walking or it's split personality. I wonder if Jonathan had an affair with Sylvia, but even so Sylvia didn't kill Elena. Henry may have promised to his mother's night counterpart to keep the hammer a secret. If someone else killed Elena I'll call it a bad script since they're just discarding so many hints from Grace.

@Regulus Sky You think it was Grace ? I think it could have been Jonathan. But either one of them could have done it, even Henry. I can see Jonathan asking Henry to hide the hammer when they were at the lake house. When Henry went to visit him in jail the first thing Jonathan ask Henry was how is the violin .

At most Henry hid it to protect his mom, since Grace certainly killed Elena.

@Владислав Мазеин yeah but he has been staying with his grandfather...

@Liv Clement thank you

Just watched this clip and Henry actually says “I never saw them kiss” then goes on to say how he knew anyway

@Francisco Alves you’re wrong bruh, Henry saw them kissing. He told Grace he saw them at the school then johnathon acted like it was nothing and waved to him. They showed the clip

@Lil neets D E L U S I O N A L. You did it. You killed her

@Francisco Alves 28min in watch again troll!!

@Regulus Sky and you were wrong lol

I don't doubt he had an affair with Sylvia, but she didn't kill Elena, that was Grace.

@geoffrobinson i doubt it but we’ll see

@johanzo88 they're setting it up with clues

Trash ending if thats the case

Remember earlier she told Grace of her history with the prosecuting attorney. I've suspected from the 2nd or 3rd episode-- whenever we learned of Jonathan's alleged one-off affair-- that she was the other party. Perhaps there will be multiple reveals... Or even multiple killers revealed.

johanzo88 How do you know?

@Marsa Andari lol

@Jessica Moore lol right

@Jessica Moore LOL thanks for reminding! I meant grace's friend

Grace doesn’t have a daughter

@Blondesense 8 hi I7h hi 8

He could be covering up for either parent but my guess is Grace too. She has been shown to have memory problems and the flashes of the crime and possibly posing for the portrait would make sense if it was her, however it could be pure imagination since she saw Elena in the dress she died in earlier that evening. He may not know which parent he is covering for. Even the grandfather can’t be ruled out because he so dearly wants to protect his daughter and grandson and Henry has had access to his home too. Perhaps he was having his son in law followed after he borrowed the 500k. We still can’t rule out the husband if Henry followed his dad to Elena’s and came upon the scene.

That makes sense because her dad could have found out about the affair and killed her to protect his daughter. But I don't think it justifies the rage of the killer...

@Perky143247 he literally could’ve worn gloves

Yeah, but the DNAs found were of Jonathan or the husband, or in the worst case Jonathan knew his son did it and covered his traces off. I don't think anyone would do this for Grace's dad.

@Proloy B LOL... It seems that *so many Americans (and perhaps others) are unfamiliar* with the concept of a *_mini-series._* Quite bizarre, as it has been done more times than can be counted, over _multiple decades._ Moreover, it was slated and stated to be six episodes *from the start.* Relieved to see you and a few others-- though small few-- who are aware.

LIMITED SERIES so...

I think it’s time for answers. There was too much story here for a movie, but no need for the suspense to drag out much further. I’m happy with the length 🤷🏼‍♀️

@Loveness phora sociopath. his mom has painted her child has having no feelings and remorse. Like when his sister died.

@Loveness phora that would be lame but ok

I think the lawyer(slyvey) knows more about Jonathan, like something happen in their affair that set her off and maybe she told that other white lady lawyer.. Maybe it was a frequent affair where he comes to her only when he lost a patient and obviosly a red flag,who tf gets hard and think sex after a person dies?

@Lil neets Remember earlier she told Grace of her history with the prosecuting attorney. I've suspected from the 2nd or 3rd episode-- whenever we learned of Jonathan's alleged one-off affair-- that she was the other party. Perhaps there will be multiple reveals... Or even multiple _killers_ revealed. How exciting!‼️ TOTALLY looking forward to the finale‼️ 🩸🥰 Also loving the overlap of "Big Sky", as I would otherwise miss the presence of such shows, which are _especially ideal_ for this time❣️

I think there is something odd about her also. She waved at the prosecution lawyer when she entered the court. Why would the director want us to see that? She knew he was off work. She represented him and tell her best friend. Maybe not the killer but guilty of not being a true friend, definitely!

But which son?

Thank you kindly ☺️😢 it’s so good

@Terry Cullen how? I get really sad when my favorite shows end, so i am saying i feel bad for people because the show they like is ending.

That's a weird thing to say...

It’s a limited series

@Chthulhu the Endless okay i was confused on why it’s so short 😅

Or Jonathan! There are only so many characters in the story that are possibilities...lol

OR the granddad knows who did it and trys to cover it!

@Ros Sen most definitely !!!!!!!!

@Stella Maybe Grace's father.

YES!!!!!! thats what im saying!!!!!!!